TEHLKA
CASE HANDED OVER TO CBI
After Uma Bharati, NDA convenor George Fernandes has been brought
into the firing line with the Centre scrapping the Phukan Commission
and handing over the Tehelka case to the CBI.
In a curious turn
of events, the Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs (CCPA)
last Friday decided to hand over the case to the CBI. Incidentally,
the decision was taken hours after the Centre told the Phukan
Commission that it did not have the mandate to probe the motive
of Tehelka. ET had reported the decision to hand-over the
case to the CBI.
That Mr Fernandes
was the target was apparent when law minister HR Bharadwaj
told reporters that the previous NDA government had "misdirected"
the justice SN Phukan Commission, whose term came to an end
on Sunday, as it wanted to "delay" and "shield"
the then defence minister.
The law minister
without taking any names, questioned the rationale behind
a private person, referring to Jaya Jaitley, staying in a
ministerial bungalow, that of Mr Fernandes. "How could
a private person function from the ministerial bungalow of
the then defence minister? Why did NDA government not probe
the minister?," he asked.
"The CCPA
has decided not to extend the term of the commission headed
by justice SN Phukan, which expired on October 3," Mr
Bharadwaj said at a press conference
The CBI has been
asked to conduct an "independent" and "speedy"
probe into the expose on deep-rooted corruption in the defence
ministry and the government would provide the video of Tehelka's
sting operation.
On whether the
UPA government had lost confidence in justice Phukan, he said
it was not a question of losing confidence, but as the commission
was not mandated to interrogate the "personalities"
figuring on the video, the government handed over the matter
to an independent investigating agency.
It is learnt that
the CBI has also been directed to examine under what circumstances
important personalities were filmed by undercover reporters
working on Operation Westend.
The minister said
that the interim report submitted to the earlier government
never gave any clean chit to Mr Fernandes, when asked to comment
on justice Phukan exonerating the former defence minister
in an interim report.
"The only
thing the commission has done so far is to send the tapes
for forensic test abroad and the report in this regard had
said that the tapes were genuine," he added.
Mr Bharadwaj said
once the veracity of the tapes were established, why would
the commission still inquire into the "motive of the
journalists," who did a "great service" by
informing people about the widespread corruption in defence
deals.
"It was the
prerogative of the government to scrap the commission. I have
not been communicated to.
Nor have I received
any phone calls," justice Phukan commented. He was of
the opinion that the CBI can register a case if it thinks
that a cognisable offence was made out.
"The NDA government
had no desire to go deep into the matter because of the involvement
of certain personalities," he said hinting at Mr Fernandes
and Bangaru Laxman, who had to step down from the BJP president's
post after he was shown to be accepting a bundle of notes.
He also said the
government was contemplating bringing a legislation to stop
"witch-hunting" against journalists, who report
about corruption in high places and public life. "Such
a legislation will also help in giving protection to witnesses,"
he added.
The NDA government,
the minister commented, had committed a lot of "wasteful
expenditure" by setting up the commission, which was
first headed by justice K Venkataswamy, who resigned under
controversial circumstances, and succeeded by justice Phukan.