CERTAIN
APPLICATIONS OF SOFTWARE THAT HAVE HARDWARE ELEMENTS CAN BE
PATENTED
Innovators in IT
can rejoice . Even as software per se would continue to be
outside the purview of patenting, embedded software as well
as software/hardware combinations would qualify for patents,
if they fulfil specified novelty conditions.
That is, certain
applications of software that have hardware elements can be
patented. The clarification is among a host of changes the
UPA government has made in the patent amendment bill, originally
drafted by the previous NDA government.
Another major amendment
in the re-drafted bill relates to protection of biological
resources from unfair patenting.
Disclosure of the
origin of materials like plants, animals and micro-organisms
would now be a mandatory pre-requisite for patents of inventions
using such material or associated knowledge.
In the patent application,
the disclosure has to be made upfront. Absence of the disclosure
can be held as reason for opposition to or rejection or revocation
of a patent, it has been freshly clarified.
India is the first
country to make such disclosure mandatory, officials said.
The aim is to avoid usurpation of traditional knowledge and
unfair patenting by use of such usurped knowledge.
Simply put, the
amendment on software patent means that software with certain
technical applications can now be patented, if reinforced
with hardware inputs.
Currently, under the Patents Act 1970 - which was amended
twice earlier - mathematical or business method or a computer
programme per se or algorithms are not patentable.
To illustrate the
present clarification with an example, examiners of a patent
application for a software that makes your washing machine
wash, rinse and dry clothes would be inclined to pass the
claim, whereas any effort to patent the "fuzzy logic"
solution independently would not pass muster.
The clarification
is a godsend for the Indian software industry, which is seeking
opportunities in embedded software and mobile computing aggressively.
The world market for embedded software solutions was estimated
at $21 billion in 2003 - expected to grow at a CAGR of 16%.
Telecommunications,
computing and data communication applications account for
34% of the world's embedded software market. Consumer electronics
account for 20%, industrial automation 19%, automotives 10%
and office automation 8%.
The new mandatory
disclosure of origin of biological resources is in keeping
with India's position in the WTO that the anti-biopiracy provisions
in the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) should reflect
in national patent laws.
Countries like
the US and Japan are opposed to the idea of mandatory disclosure.
They argue that CBD compliance should be found outside the
TRIPS and patent laws.
The bill has sought
to harmonise the patent act with the biodiversity act and
the mandate of the proposed biodiversity authority.